Howard Phillips Lovecraft, commonly known as H.P. Lovecraft, remains an enigmatic and controversial figure in the literary world. Born on August 20, 1890, in Providence, Rhode Island, Lovecraft’s life was marred by personal tragedies and social isolation, significantly influencing his writing. His early childhood was marked by the mental illness of his parents, both of whom were institutionalized, leaving him to be raised by his grandfather. This isolation and family trauma fed into the creation of his unique literary universe.

Lovecraft’s strengths as a writer lie in his ability to conjure up a sense of cosmic dread and the ineffable horror of the unknown. His stories often feature protagonists who encounter ancient, malevolent entities or discover unsettling truths about the universe, leading to their inevitable descent into madness. Though sometimes criticized for being overly verbose, his writing style creates an immersive atmosphere that has profoundly influenced the horror genre. His concept of a shared universe, known as the “Cthulhu Mythos,” has become a foundational element in modern horror and weird fiction.

However, Lovecraft’s work is not without its weaknesses. His narratives can be dense and archaic, potentially alienating to modern readers. Moreover, his personal views, particularly his overt racism, have rightly become a subject of significant criticism. These views were not only unique but often seeped into his writings, tainting some of his stories with racial stereotypes and bigoted ideologies. It’s essential to address and critically examine these aspects rather than ignore them, as they are part of the complex legacy he left behind.

Despite these significant flaws, Lovecraft’s impact on horror and science fiction is undeniable. His creation of a mythos that combines elements of horror, fantasy, and science fiction has inspired countless writers and artists. Lovecraftian horror, characterized by the fear of the unknown and the insignificance of humanity in the face of incomprehensible cosmic forces, has become a genre unto itself.

Lovecraft’s ability to tap into our deepest fears – of the unknown, the incomprehensible, and the inevitable decline into chaos – is what makes his stories so seminal and influential. He explored themes ahead of his time, delving into existential dread and the fragility of human sanity in the face of the vast, uncaring universe.

Below you will find the pinnacle of Lovecraft’s literary works, and the absolute apex of horror that he produced. Join me as we count down his 30 best tales that have haunted readers’ imaginations for nearly a century.

---

The Best of H.P. Lovecraft

---

30. “The Tomb” (1922)

In “The Tomb,” first published in “The Vagrant”, Lovecraft weaves a story of a young man, Jervas Dudley, who becomes obsessed with a family tomb he discovers in the woods. The tale blurs the lines between reality and delusion, exploring the depths of psychological horror. Lovecraft’s first-person narrative intensifies the sense of unreality and the protagonist’s descent into madness.

29. “The Alchemist” (1908)

One of Lovecraft’s earliest works, first published in “The United Amateur,” “The Alchemist” unfolds the centuries-long tale of revenge and a family curse. The narrative chronicles the last descendant of the d’Erlette family unraveling a dark secret about an alchemist’s vow of vengeance. This early story sets the stage for Lovecraft’s recurring themes of ancestral curses and forbidden knowledge.

28. “The Statement of Randolph Carter” (1920)

This short story initially appeared in “The Vagrant”, and is a first-person account of a horrifying experience in an ancient underground cemetery. The narrative is based on a dream Lovecraft had, and it excels in creating a sense of dread and the unknown, as Carter recounts his friend’s descent into an unseen horror.

27. “From Beyond” (1934)

First appearing in “The Fantasy Fan”, “From Beyond” sees Lovecraft delving into the unseen realms that exist parallel to our own. The story concerns a scientist who invents a machine that allows people to perceive creatures from another dimension. The tale is a chilling exploration of the unknown and the unintended consequences of tampering with the fabric of reality.

26. “The Horror at Red Hook” (1927)

This story first appeared in “Weird Tales”. It is set in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Red Hook, and revolves around the investigation of a police detective into the sinister occurrences and cult activities in the area. It’s a tale of urban horror, mixing themes of xenophobia (reflecting Lovecraft’s own problematic views) and the supernatural. While not as celebrated as his other works, it provides insight into Lovecraft’s views on urbanization and its discontents.

25. “The Lurking Fear” (1923)

Initially published in “Home Brew,” this tale delves into the theme of hereditary curses. Set in the Catskill Mountains, the story follows an unnamed protagonist investigating a series of gruesome happenings. Lovecraft weaves a narrative of degeneration and horror, both physical and moral, portraying a family’s descent into inhumanity. The horror in “The Lurking Fear” is visceral, tied to the earth and genetics, contrasting his usual cosmic dread.

24. “The Festival” (1925)

Published in “Weird Tales,” “The Festival” takes us to the ancient town of Kingsport, where age-old rites and eldritch traditions are observed. This story stands out for its vivid description of the town and its sinister festival, giving us a glimpse into the hidden, archaic horrors that lie beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary locales.

23. “The Doom That Came to Sarnath” (1920)

This story, which appeared in “The Scot,” is a foray into fantasy set in a mythical past. It tells the tale of the city of Sarnath, which rises to glory after brutally conquering the non-human inhabitants of a neighboring city. The story is a morality play on the consequences of hubris and xenophobia, showcasing Lovecraft’s talent for creating rich, imaginary worlds.

22. “The Outsider” (1926)

Featured in “Weird Tales,” this short story is one of Lovecraft’s most poignant works. It’s a first-person account of someone who has lived in isolation in a dark, ancient castle. When they finally escape, the protagonist’s encounter with the outside world leads to a shocking self-realization. This story is notable for its gothic atmosphere and its exploration of loneliness and identity.

21. “The Music of Erich Zann” (1922)

This story, appearing in “The National Amateur,” presents the tale of a university student drawn to a mysterious old musician, Erich Zann, whose otherworldly music seems to hold back some unknown cosmic horror. The story is a testament to Lovecraft’s ability to evoke terror through the unseen and unheard.

20. “The Temple” (1925)

This tale of underwater discovery and madness follows a German U-boat commander who retrieves a cursed idol from a sunken ship. As the crew descends into madness and death, the story builds up to a climactic and otherworldly revelation. “The Temple” showcases Lovecraft’s ability to fuse historical settings with his trademark themes of ancient, unknowable horrors.

19. “The Cats of Ulthar” (1920)

A departure from his usual horror, “The Cats of Ulthar” is a fantasy tale set in a mythical town where it becomes forbidden to kill cats after a series of mysterious events. This story reflects Lovecraft’s personal affection for cats and offers a lighter, yet still eerie narrative, rich with mythical overtones.

18. “The Nameless City” (1921)

Set in a desolate part of the Arabian desert, “The Nameless City” is often considered the first story of the Cthulhu Mythos. The protagonist explores a mysterious, ancient city, uncovering the truth of its inhuman, reptilian inhabitants. The story’s atmosphere of desolation and the theme of a long-forgotten, non-human civilization are classic Lovecraft.

17. “The Whisperer in Darkness” (1931)

Published in “Weird Tales,” this story marks Lovecraft’s foray into science fiction horror. Set in rural Vermont, it follows a folklore professor who becomes entangled in a horrifying discovery involving alien entities and their sinister intentions. The blend of epistolary narrative and chilling cosmic revelations showcases Lovecraft’s ability to merge the unknown with scientific elements.

16. “Cool Air” (1928)

Appearing in “Tales of Magic and Mystery,” this story is a departure from Lovecraft’s usual cosmic horror, focusing instead on a more personal, psychological horror. It tells the story of a reclusive doctor who has developed a bizarre method to prolong his life. The climax reveals a grotesque and tragic twist, highlighting Lovecraft’s versatility in horror storytelling.

15. “The Case of Charles Dexter Ward” (1941)

Published posthumously in “Weird Tales,” this novel-length work is a complex tale of ancestral legacy and necromancy. It chronicles Charles Dexter Ward’s descent into his ancestors’ occult practices. This story is a rich tapestry of Lovecraft’s themes, blending historical narrative with supernatural elements and showcasing his skill in creating a slowly building atmosphere of dread.

14. “The Haunter of the Dark” (1936)

Featured in “Weird Tales,” this story is a sequel to “The Shambler from the Stars” by Robert Bloch, a friend and protégé of Lovecraft. It follows a writer’s encounter with an ancient entity lurking in a forsaken church in Providence. The tale is notable for exploring forbidden knowledge and the inevitable doom that follows its pursuit.

13. “The Hound” (1924)

A story of grave-robbing and supernatural revenge, “The Hound” recounts the tale of two men who unearth a jade amulet from an ancient grave, invoking a terrifying spectral hound. The story is known for its gothic atmosphere and is an early example of Lovecraft’s exploration of the necrotic and the macabre.

12. “Dagon” (1919)

“Dagon” is a short story that introduces readers to Lovecraft’s cosmic horror. The protagonist, a morphine-addicted World War I veteran, recounts his encounter with a monstrous sea deity. The story’s depiction of the vast, uncaring universe and the smallness of humanity is a precursor to the themes Lovecraft would further develop in his Cthulhu Mythos.

11. “The Thing on the Doorstep” (1937)

Appearing in “Weird Tales,” this story is a chilling narrative involving body-swapping and ancient rites. It tells the tale of a man whose wife is involved in sinister, arcane practices, culminating in a horrifying revelation. The story is a blend of psychological horror and the macabre, demonstrating Lovecraft’s ability to create terror through both the psychological and the supernatural.

10. “The Shadow Out of Time” (1936)

Published in “Astounding Stories,” this novella is a profound exploration of time, identity, and alien life. It follows a professor who experiences amnesia and later discovers that his consciousness was exchanged with that of an alien being. The story is a fascinating blend of science fiction and horror, exploring the vastness of time and the insignificance of humanity.

9. “The Colour Out of Space” (1927)

Appearing in “Amazing Stories,” this tale is a masterpiece of extraterrestrial horror. A meteorite crashes near a rural farm, emitting a strange substance that has catastrophic effects on the land and its inhabitants. This story is celebrated for portraying an incomprehensible alien force, embodying the essence of cosmic horror.

8. “The Dreams in the Witch House” (1933)

Published in “Weird Tales,” this story blends the occult with theoretical physics, exploring the frightening possibilities of other dimensions. The protagonist, a student, rents a room in a house with a dark history and finds himself entangled in a nightmare that transcends time and space. The story stands out for its innovative combination of science and witchcraft, a hallmark of Lovecraft’s later works.

7. “The Dunwich Horror” (1929)

This tale, published in “Weird Tales,” explores themes of forbidden knowledge and its catastrophic consequences. Set in the rural town of Dunwich, it chronicles the terrifying aftermath of an unholy union between a human woman and an otherworldly entity. The story’s mix of rural folklore and cosmic horror is quintessentially Lovecraftian.

6. “Herbert West–Reanimator” (1922)

Initially serialized in “Home Brew,” this story marks Lovecraft’s foray into the science fiction horror genre. It tells the tale of Herbert West, a medical student obsessed with overcoming death, leading to grotesque and unforeseen consequences. This work stands out for its explicit gore and macabre humor, a departure from Lovecraft’s typical style.

5. “The Shadow Over Innsmouth” (1936)

First published as a book by Visionary Publishing Company, this novella is a cornerstone of the Cthulhu Mythos. It details the protagonist’s harrowing experience in Innsmouth, a decaying seaport town with a disturbing history. The story’s exploration of degeneration and the blurring line between human and non-human entities is quintessentially Lovecraftian.

4. “Pickman’s Model” (1927)

Published in “Weird Tales,” this story delves into the world of art, horror, and the uncanny. It revolves around an artist, Richard Pickman, whose horrifyingly realistic paintings suggest a sinister truth. The tale is a masterclass in building tension and terror, culminating in a shocking revelation.

3. “The Rats in the Walls” (1924)

Another “Weird Tales” offering. This creepy tale tells of a man haunted by the sounds of scurrying rats within the walls of his restored ancestral home, Exham Priory. His investigation uncovers a ghastly history of cannibalism and dark rituals practiced by his ancestors. This descent into madness culminates in a shocking, gruesome revelation, embodying Lovecraft’s signature themes of cosmic horror and the unknown. One of The Longbox of Darkness’ personal favorites.

2. “At the Mountains of Madness” (1936)

Originally published in “Astounding Stories,” this novella is a seminal work in Lovecraft’s canon, detailing an Antarctic expedition’s discovery of an ancient alien city. The detailed world-building and the overwhelming sense of isolation and ancient terror make it a landmark in the Cthulhu Mythos and in horror literature.

1. “The Call of Cthulhu” (1928)

First appearing in “Weird Tales,” this is arguably Lovecraft’s most famous work and the centerpiece of the Cthulhu Mythos. The story unfolds through various narratives, revealing the existence of Cthulhu, an ancient cosmic deity. Its theme of incomprehensible cosmic horrors has become synonymous with Lovecraftian horror and has profoundly influenced the horror genre.

---

In these stories, Lovecraft reaches the zenith of his literary powers, blending his unique brand of cosmic horror with explorations into human psychology, the nature of reality, and the dark corners of the universe. They represent not only the peak of Lovecraft’s creativity but also a significant milestone in the evolution of the horror genre.

Final Thoughts and an Invitation to the Abyss

As we conclude our exploration of H.P. Lovecraft’s top 25 stories, it’s clear why his work continues to resonate in horror and science fiction. Lovecraft’s unique brand of cosmic horror — emphasizing humanity’s incomprehensible and insignificance in the face of vast, uncaring cosmic forces — has not only shaped the horror genre but also left an indelible mark on popular culture.

What sets Lovecraft apart is his ability to tap into our most primal fears — not just the fear of the unknown, but the fear of the unknowable. His stories challenge our perceptions of reality and our place in the universe, often leaving us with existential dread long after turning the final page.

While Lovecraft’s legacy is tainted by his abhorrent personal views, his contributions to literature cannot be ignored. Readers and scholars must engage with his work critically, acknowledging its influence while examining the problematic aspects of his personal beliefs and how they seeped into his writings.

As horror fans and enthusiasts, we continue to grapple with these complexities, finding ways to appreciate the art without excusing the artist’s faults. Lovecraft’s stories, with their eldritch horrors and haunting narratives, invite us to confront the darkness in the world around us and within ourselves.

Now, I turn to you, fear addicts: What are your thoughts on Lovecraft’s works? Which story resonates with you the most, and why? Are there aspects of his writing that you find particularly compelling or problematic?

I encourage you to share your insights and opinions in the comments section below.

If you enjoyed this journey through the abyss of cosmic horror, don’t forget to subscribe to the blog for more content on horror literature, film, comics, art, and more. Thanks for reading, and remember to keep a wary eye on the cosmic void that is ever-present, and ever-eager to plunge us into the abyss of insanity 😉

---