Hola, Dwellers in Darkness!

It’s been 25 years since DC Comics launched its legendary Vertigo imprint, which aimed to release more adult stories free from censorship to rabid comic book fans like us. Vertigo quickly became a critical and financial success, attracting some of the best creators in the industry. Sadly, in recent years, the imprint has lost its luster. I still remember it fondly, though, and find myself constantly re-reading some of its gems. So in this article, just for the hell of it, I’ll rank the 15 best Vertigo series published over the last 25 years. Here goes…

Part 1: Dystopian Visions and Fantasy Realms

16. The Books of Magic – A Journey Through the Mystical Corners of the DC Universe

“The Books of Magic,” initially a miniseries by Sandman creator Neil Gaiman and later an ongoing series, takes readers on a magical journey through the mystical corners of the DC universe. The story follows Timothy Hunter, a young boy destined to become the world’s greatest magician, as he navigates the complexities of magic and its impact on his life.

The series is a celebration of the magical and mystical elements of the DC universe, blending the wonder of fantasy with the grounded, character-driven storytelling that Vertigo is known for. “The Books of Magic” provides a rich exploration of themes such as destiny, the cost of power, and the challenges of growing up.

The artwork in the series, featuring various artists over its run, beautifully captures the enchanting and sometimes dark world of magic. “The Books of Magic” is not just a tale of wizardry; it’s a coming-of-age story set in a world where magic is real and often dangerous.

In this segment, we explored the depths of “Animal Man,” the philosophical richness of Mike Carey’s “Lucifer,” and the enchanting world of “The Books of Magic.” Each of these Vertigo series offers a unique take on their respective genres, showcasing the imprint’s commitment to storytelling that is both imaginative and thought-provoking.

15. Twisted Vignettes – The Psychological Horrors of ‘Flinch’

“Flinch,” a lesser-known but significant title from Vertigo, is a treasure trove of short stories that delve into the realms of psychological horror, dark fantasy, and twisted morality. This series stands out for its ability to pack a punch within the constraints of a short story format, offering a diverse array of narratives that are as thought-provoking as they are unsettling.

Each story in “Flinch” is crafted by different writers and artists, bringing a unique flavor and perspective to the anthology. The series is a showcase of the diversity and depth that the horror genre can offer, with stories ranging from eerie supernatural tales to disturbing psychological journeys. The artwork varies from story to story, but consistently maintains a high quality, with styles that enhance the mood and theme of each narrative.

“Flinch” is proof of the versatility of the comic book medium, showing that impactful and memorable stories can come in small packages. It’s a must-read for fans of horror and dark storytelling, offering a kaleidoscope of nightmares and fantasies that linger in the mind long after the pages are turned.

14. Lucifer – Mike Carey’s Exploration of Free Will and Destiny

Mike Carey’s “Lucifer,” spun off from Neil Gaiman’s “Sandman” series, is a rich narrative tapestry that weaves together elements of mythology, theology, and fantasy. The series follows Lucifer Morningstar, the former lord of Hell, as he embarks on a journey that challenges preconceived notions of fate and free will.

Carey’s writing in “Lucifer” is both eloquent and provocative, creating a world that’s as intellectually stimulating as it is entertaining. The series explores complex themes such as destiny, the nature of evil, and the quest for individuality, all through the lens of its charismatic and morally ambiguous protagonist.

The art, primarily by Peter Gross, captures the series’ blend of the mundane and the divine, with visuals that range from the gritty reality of Earth to the fantastical realms beyond. “Lucifer” stands out as a deeply philosophical and beautifully crafted series, offering a unique perspective on classic biblical and mythological themes.

13. Transmetropolitan – A Satirical Lens on Society’s Future

Next on our list is “Transmetropolitan”, a series that dives headfirst into the chaos of a cyberpunk future. Crafted by Warren Ellis and Darick Robertson, this comic is far more than just a dystopian narrative; it’s a mirror held up to our society, reflecting the absurdities of politics, media, and celebrity culture.

The protagonist, Spider Jerusalem, is a journalist with an attitude as sharp as his intellect. Through his eyes, Ellis and Robertson guide us through a future that is both outlandishly alien and uncomfortably familiar. The narrative is a cocktail of dark humor and biting social commentary, making “Transmetropolitan” a series that is as thought-provoking as it is entertaining.

The art by Robertson is a visual feast, capturing the frenetic energy of the series’ setting. Each panel bursts with details that build a world both rich and bizarre, mirroring the complexity and chaos of the narrative itself. “Transmetropolitan” isn’t just a story; it’s a satirical exploration of what our future could be, making it a standout in the Vertigo lineup.

12. Fables – A Modern Twist on Classic Tales

At number 12, we enter the imaginative world of “Fables”. Bill Willingham, with the artistic prowess of Mark Buckingham, brings a fresh perspective to the characters from fairy tales and folklore. Here, these iconic figures are not just confined to the pages of children’s stories; they are living, breathing entities trying to navigate the complexities of our world.

“Fables” is a series that masterfully blends the whimsical elements of fairy tales with the stark realities of modern life. The narrative explores themes of exile, identity, and the struggle for power, all through the lens of familiar characters like Snow White, Bigby Wolf, and Prince Charming. Buckingham’s art brings these tales to life with a style that is both charming and evocative, perfectly complementing Willingham’s storytelling.

The series also delves into deeper issues of war, love, and family dynamics, presenting these timeless characters in a way that is both innovative and respectful to their origins. “Fables” is more than just a comic; it’s a socio-political allegory wrapped in the guise of fantasy, making it a compelling read for fans of both genres.

11. The Invisibles – A Journey Through Layers of Reality

Ranking 11th is “The Invisibles”, a series that defies traditional categorization. Grant Morrison’s creation is a psychedelic trip through various layers of reality, conspiracy theories, and metaphysical experiences. The narrative follows a group of rebels, the titular Invisibles, as they wage a covert war against alien enslavement and societal oppression.

Morrison’s writing in “The Invisibles” is a labyrinthine journey through different times, dimensions, and realities. It challenges readers to question the nature of their existence and the constructs of society. The series blends a variety of influences, from pop culture to esoteric philosophy, creating a narrative tapestry that is as bewildering as it is captivating.

The art in “The Invisibles” is a crucial component of its storytelling, with each panel crafted to enhance the surreal and often chaotic nature of Morrison’s writing. The series is a mind-bending exploration of freedom, control, and the human spirit, placing it firmly as a standout title in the Vertigo catalogue.

In this segment, we explored the dystopian visions of “Transmetropolitan”, the modern fairy tale reimaginings of “Fables”, and the reality-bending narrative of “The Invisibles”. Each of these series showcases the breadth and depth of storytelling that Vertigo comics are known for, blending imaginative worlds with thought-provoking themes.

Part 2: Groundbreaking Storytelling

10. 100 Bullets – A Dish Best Served Cold

“100 Bullets” is a series that masterfully intertwines the concept of justice with the human desire for vengeance. Brian Azzarello and Eduardo Risso have created not just a comic book, but a complex tapestry of morality and retribution.

The premise of “100 Bullets” is deceptively simple: individuals are given a gun and 100 untraceable bullets to exact revenge as they see fit. However, Azzarello’s narrative is anything but straightforward. It’s a deep dive into the human psyche, exploring themes of guilt, revenge, and the moral ambiguity of justice. Risso’s artwork complements this narrative beautifully, with a noir-esque style that adds depth and gravity to the story.

Each character in “100 Bullets” is meticulously crafted, their stories intertwining in a grand, often tragic, narrative. The series isn’t just about the action; it’s a psychological journey, making readers question the very nature of right and wrong. This moral complexity, combined with stunning visuals, makes “100 Bullets” a standout series in the Vertigo lineup.

9. American Vampire – A Fresh Take on Vampire Lore

“American Vampire,” a standout series in the Vertigo lineup, presents a refreshing and unique take on vampire mythology. This series, created by Scott Snyder and illustrated by Rafael Albuquerque, interweaves the traditional elements of vampire tales with new, innovative concepts.

Set across various decades of American history, “American Vampire” introduces us to a new breed of vampire, born from the American soil. The narrative primarily follows Skinner Sweet, the first of this new species, and Pearl Jones, a young woman turned into a vampire, as they navigate through the changing landscape of the 20th century.

Snyder’s storytelling is a masterful blend of horror, history, and character-driven drama. He reinvigorates the vampire genre by infusing it with historical depth and a uniquely American perspective. Albuquerque’s art complements this by bringing the eras and emotions to life with a style that is both gritty and glamorous, perfectly capturing the essence of the story.

“American Vampire” stands out for its originality and its ability to add new layers to the well-trodden path of vampire fiction. It’s a series that not only entertains but also challenges the norms of its genre, making it a must-read for fans of horror and historical fiction.

8. Animal Man – A Hero’s Journey Beyond the Panels

“Animal Man,” a series that stands out in the Vertigo universe for breaking the fourth wall, offers a unique blend of superhero adventure and metaphysical exploration. The series, particularly under the direction of writer Grant Morrison, took the character of Buddy Baker, a man with animal powers, and transformed his story into something extraordinary.

Morrison’s approach to “Animal Man” was revolutionary, infusing the narrative with existential questions and breaking the fourth wall in ways that were unheard of in superhero comics. The series delves deep into themes of environmentalism, animal rights, and the very nature of comic book reality. It’s a story that challenges readers’ perceptions of what a superhero can be, elevating a relatively obscure character to new heights of narrative complexity.

The artwork in “Animal Man,” particularly by Chas Truog, along with stunning covers by Brian Bolland, complements the story’s blend of the mundane and the surreal, bringing to life the series’ unique tone and themes. “Animal Man” is more than a superhero comic; it’s a thought-provoking journey into the heart of storytelling itself.

7. The Doom Patrol – Superheroes Deconstructed

“The Doom Patrol” is another gem in the Vertigo collection, known for its surreal and avant-garde approach to the superhero genre. The series, with notable contributions from writers like Grant Morrison, redefines what a superhero comic can be, delving into abstract and often bizarre territories.

This series revolves around a group of super-powered misfits, each with abilities that are more of a curse than a blessing. The team, led by the enigmatic Chief, tackles threats that are as unconventional as they are themselves, often venturing into realms of the psychological and the surreal.

Morrison’s tenure on “The Doom Patrol” is particularly acclaimed for its innovative storytelling, blending elements of science fiction, psychological horror, and dadaism. The series is known for its willingness to explore complex and often taboo topics, pushing the envelope of what superhero stories can encompass.

“The Doom Patrol” is not just a comic book; it’s a foray into the depths of the human psyche, packaged in a superhero narrative. It’s a series that invites readers to question the norms of both society and the superhero genre itself.

These two Vertigo titles, “American Vampire” and “The Doom Patrol,” showcase the imprint’s commitment to diverse and innovative storytelling. Whether it’s reinventing a classic horror myth or deconstructing the superhero archetype, these series represent the creative spirit that Vertigo is known for.

6. Preacher – The Profane with the Divine

“Preacher” is a series that defies convention at every turn. Created by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon, it’s a story that blends violence, dark humor, and theological themes into an utterly unique narrative.

The series follows Jesse Custer, a preacher in a small Texas town, who becomes possessed by a supernatural entity. This possession sets him on a quest, but this is no ordinary journey. It’s a road trip through the heart of America, filled with bizarre characters, surreal situations, and deep philosophical questions about faith and existence.

Ennis’s writing in “Preacher” is fearless, tackling subjects that most would shy away from. His characters are deeply flawed but incredibly compelling, driving a story that’s as thought-provoking as it is entertaining. Dillon’s art is a perfect match for this narrative, capturing both the grotesque and the divine with equal skill.

“Preacher” is more than just a comic; it’s an exploration of the human condition, wrapped in a tale of angels, demons, and everything in between. Its blend of irreverent humor and deep thematic content has not only garnered a dedicated fanbase but also secured its place in comic book history.

Part 3: The Pinnacle of Vertigo’s Creative Expression

5. Y: The Last Man – A Post-Apocalyptic Exploration of Gender and Society

“Y: The Last Man,” claiming the fifth position in our ranking, is a series that takes a simple, yet profound premise to explore the depths of human society and gender dynamics. Created by Brian K. Vaughan and Pia Guerra, the series presents a world where every male mammal suddenly dies, except for one man, Yorick, and his pet monkey.

This unique setup allows Vaughan and Guerra to delve deep into the societal structures, examining the roles of men and women in a world turned upside down. The narrative is a blend of adventure, mystery, and social commentary, providing a poignant look at issues such as power, survival, and the human need for connection.

Guerra’s art is a vital part of the storytelling, capturing the emotional depth and the expansive world-building with finesse. The series is a compelling mix of a gripping narrative and thought-provoking themes, making “Y: The Last Man” a groundbreaking work in the realm of graphic novels.

4. Scalped (#10) – A Deep Dive into a Gritty Narrative

In the 4th spot of our exploration into the Vertigo universe, we encounter “Scalped”. This series, crafted by Jason Aaron and vividly illustrated by RM Guéra, drags us into the raw and unflinching world of the Prairie Rose Indian Reservation. The narrative orbits around Dashiell Bad Horse, a character with layers as complex as the story itself. Bad Horse, an undercover FBI agent, finds himself ensnared back into the web of his own tumultuous past.

Aaron’s storytelling prowess in “Scalped” is not just about spinning a good yarn; it’s about excavating the deeper layers of human emotions and societal issues. He weaves a tale that mirrors the real struggles on reservations, touching on the nerve of native rights, identity crises, and the relentless pursuit of justice. Guéra’s art, with its raw and evocative strokes, complements Aaron’s dark narrative, painting a picture of the reservation life that’s both haunting and deeply real.

“Scalped” isn’t just a crime drama; it’s a sociopolitical commentary wrapped in a suspense thriller. Over its 60-issue run, the series maintained a razor-sharp focus on the themes of betrayal, redemption, and the blurry lines between. It’s a narrative that forces the reader to look beyond the black and white and dive into the gray shades of morality and justice.

3. Sandman – A Masterpiece of Myth and Imagination

Near the summit of our list stands “The Sandman,” a series that is not just a comic book but a mythos in its own right. Written by Neil Gaiman, this series introduced readers to Morpheus, the Lord of Dreams, and took them on a journey through realms both fantastical and eerily familiar.

“The Sandman” is a series that transcends genre boundaries, blending elements of horror, fantasy, and mythology into a narrative tapestry that is both sprawling and intimate. Gaiman’s storytelling is rich and multifaceted, weaving various mythologies with original tales to create a world that is as vast as it is detailed.

The series’ art, contributed by various artists throughout its run, complements Gaiman’s storytelling with a visual style that ranges from the ethereal to the nightmarish. “Sandman” has not only garnered critical acclaim and a devoted fanbase but has also influenced a generation of writers and artists, making it a cornerstone of not just Vertigo, but the comic book medium as a whole.

2. Hellblazer – The Cult of John Constantine

Landing at number 2 is “Hellblazer”, a series that is as iconic as its trench-coat-wearing protagonist, John Constantine. This series not only stands as Vertigo’s longest-running series but also as a testament to the imprint’s dedication to complex, mature storytelling.

Constantine, a cynic and a sorcerer, navigates through the shadowy corners of the DC universe, dealing with both the supernatural and the human evils. “Hellblazer” became a canvas for some of the most innovative writers in the industry, including Garth Ennis, Warren Ellis, and Grant Morrison. Each brought their unique flair to the series, yet maintained the core essence of Constantine’s character – a flawed hero, battling his own demons as much as the external ones.

The series was groundbreaking not just for its mature content but also for its portrayal of pressing social issues, all filtered through the lens of dark humor and occult mysticism. Constantine’s moral ambiguity, coupled with the series’ bold storytelling, makes “Hellblazer” a must-read for anyone seeking a deep, character-driven narrative.

1. Saga of the Swamp Thing – A Pioneer in Gothic Storytelling

Predictably (if you are familiar with The Longbox of Darkness at all), at number 1, we gleefully wade into the murky depths of “Saga of the Swamp Thing”, my favorite comic book series. This isn’t merely a comic; it’s a piece of gothic art. Helmed by the legendary Alan Moore and brought to life by the talented Stephen Bissette, this series redefined what was possible in the world of graphic novels.

Alan Moore’s “Saga of the Swamp Thing” transcended typical comic book storytelling, venturing into uncharted territories of mysticism, horror, and environmental consciousness. It’s here we see Moore’s genius in reimagining the Swamp Thing not just as a creature, but as an elemental force with a profound connection to the very essence of life and death. Bissette’s art perfectly encapsulates this gothic and ethereal world, with its dark palettes and intricate detailing adding layers to Moore’s already dense storytelling.

This series set a precedent for mature-themed comics and opened the floodgates for future Vertigo titles. It wasn’t just a comic; it was a narrative revolution, encapsulating themes of love, loss, and what it means to be human, all woven into the life of a creature from the depths of the swamp.

Honorable Mentions: Other Noteworthy Vertigo Titles

Sweet Tooth – A Post-Apocalyptic Tale of Survival and Humanity

“Sweet Tooth,” created by Jeff Lemire, is a compelling post-apocalyptic narrative that combines elements of horror, science fiction, and drama. The series follows Gus, a young boy with deer-like features, as he navigates a world ravaged by a mysterious pandemic. It’s a story of survival, humanity, and the search for a safe haven in a world that’s lost its way.

iZombie – A Fresh Spin on the Undead Genre

“iZombie,” by Chris Roberson and Michael Allred, offers a quirky and unique take on the zombie genre. The series centers on Gwen, a zombie who retains her humanity by eating brains, which also grants her the memories of the deceased. “iZombie” is a mix of mystery, horror, and comedy, providing a fresh and entertaining perspective on the undead.

DMZ – A Political Thriller in a War-Torn New York

“DMZ,” created by Brian Wood and Riccardo Burchielli, is a political thriller set in a near-future America torn apart by a second civil war. The series focuses on Matty Roth, a journalist trapped in the demilitarized zone of Manhattan, as he uncovers the truth behind the conflict. “DMZ” is a gripping tale of war, politics, and the human spirit.

Northlanders – A Gritty Exploration of Viking Life

“Northlanders,” by Brian Wood, is a series that brings to life the harsh and brutal world of the Vikings. Through various standalone stories and arcs, “Northlanders” explores different aspects of Viking culture, from warfare and exploration to daily life and spirituality. The series is known for its historical accuracy and raw storytelling.

Unwritten – A Metafictional Adventure Through Literature

“Unwritten,” by Mike Carey and Peter Gross, is a metafictional series that blurs the line between reality and literature. The story follows Tom Taylor, whose life is intertwined with a famous fictional character created by his father. “Unwritten” is a journey through classic literature and a deep dive into the power of stories.

These honorable mentions, along with the previously discussed titles, showcase the rich and diverse storytelling that Vertigo comics have offered over the years. Each series, in its own way, has pushed the boundaries of the comic book medium, offering readers a blend of innovative narratives and thought-provoking themes.

The Wrap-Up

In this journey through the best of DC Vertigo series, I’ve tried to showcase the breadth and depth of storytelling that this imprint has offered us over the years. From the gritty, socially-aware narratives of “Scalped” and “Transmetropolitan” to the mythic and imaginative worlds of “Sandman” and “Fables,” there can be no doubt that Vertigo has consistently pushed the boundaries of comic book storytelling.

These series have not only captivated readers with their complex characters and immersive worlds but have also left their stamp on the comic book industry. They’ve explored themes of justice, existentialism, and the human condition in ways that are thought-provoking and deeply entertaining. This, to me, is why Vertigo will always remain an imprint that I will remember fondly and with reverence.

---

If you’re looking to experience the pinnacle of illustrated storytelling, delve into these top-rated DC Vertigo comics mentioned above. And if you’re already an established fan of this legendary imprint, leave your thoughts in the comments below, and mention your personal favorites. If you’re up for more spine-tingling, thought-provoking content in the world of horror and beyond, delivered straight to your inbox, don’t forget to subscribe to the blog.

Thanks for visiting LOD, Dark Travelers. Until next time, pleasant screams!